# PPE interview questions: separate the position, the reasons and the counterexample

> Five original PPE interview problems on distributive fairness, legitimacy, liberty and harm, trade and medical triage, with what each tests and how to argue.

[Formatted version of this page](https://www.frontiervue.com/interviews/questions/ppe)

PPE interviews draw on philosophy, politics and economics, but the common thread is argument. The interviewer does not care which side you take; they care whether you can state a position, connect reasons to conclusions, and engage with the strongest objection. These five are **original practice**.

## Key takeaways
- Give the conclusion, then the reasons, then engage the strongest objection yourself.
- Separate factual disputes from value disputes; many arguments become clearer immediately.
- Test a principle against a concrete case; it is more persuasive than an abstract slogan.

### PPE interviews at a glance

| Item | Value |
| --- | --- |
| Format | Open questions and follow-ups |
| Question style | Normative and policy questions |
| What matters | Reasons, counterexamples, consistency |
| How to prepare | Pair each position with its best objection |

> Do not support both sides to sound sophisticated. State a position, then say under what conditions you would revise it.

> What the format looks like: The interview usually starts with an open question, then asks why, what if the case changes, and whether your principle implies something you would reject. Revising your position is not weakness; it is part of arguing well.

## Contents
1. What a PPE interview is testing
2. How to use these five problems

## 1. What a PPE interview is testing

A PPE interview is not a quiz. The interviewer assumes you have read some things but wants to know whether you can use them on a concrete question. On whether the rich should pay a higher tax rate, the point is not the rate but which conception of fairness you rely on, what incentives follow, and who bears the cost.

Good answers tend to have three features: a clear position, layered reasons and a concrete counterexample. You may revise your position at the end, but let the interviewer see why, rather than swaying to please them.

> When asked which side you support, use **“I lean towards …, because …; but I worry that …”**. It gives you a position without pretending the issue is simple.

## 2. How to use these five problems

1. **State a position**
Answer should or should not in one sentence. Do not open with background.

2. **Give two layers of reasons** (Core)
One principle, one consequence. Principle alone is empty; consequences alone drift.

3. **State the strongest objection**
Do not pick a weak target. State the best version of the opposing case, then respond.

4. **Use a concrete case**
Test your principle on a real or hypothetical case and see whether it implies something absurd.

## 5 PPE interview problems

Every problem below is original practice written for this site, not a past paper. Read the question, try it aloud, then compare your reasoning with the approach.

### Question 1

**Prompt:** Is it fair to tax a billionaire at a higher rate than a teacher? Argue both sides, then say which you find more convincing and why.

**What this tests：** This tests distributive justice, incentives and tax incidence. The interviewer wants you to distinguish who legally pays from who actually bears the cost.

**How to work through it：**
1. The case for progressive taxation: ability to pay, diminishing marginal utility, unequal opportunity, and the greater benefit the wealthy receive from public institutions.
2. The case against: property rights, incentives and investment, incidence that may fall on workers or consumers, and enforcement and capital-flight costs.
3. Give your judgement and say which value it depends on: if equal opportunity matters most, you will accept a higher rate; if incentives and property rights matter most, you will be more cautious.

**The likely follow-up:** Would your answer change if the billionaire’s income came mainly from capital gains rather than wages?

### Question 2

**Prompt:** A government wins an election with 40% of the vote. Is that democratic? What does democracy require beyond voting?

**What this tests：** This tests democratic legitimacy, electoral systems and institutional constraints. The key is to distinguish procedural legitimacy from substantive representation.

**How to work through it：**
1. Under first-past-the-post, 40% of the vote can produce a majority of seats. That is procedurally legitimate, but it does not mean 40% represents everyone.
2. Democracy also includes regular elections, the rule of law, an independent judiciary, a free press, opposition rights and peaceful transfer of power. Without those, voting is only a form.
3. Proportional representation may reflect votes more accurately but can produce coalitions and fragmentation. Choosing an electoral system is itself a trade-off, not a purely moral question.

**The likely follow-up:** Does low turnout weaken a government’s legitimacy? Why?

### Question 3

**Prompt:** Should a government ban a drug that harms only the person who takes it? Use Mill’s harm principle first, then say whether you agree with it.

**What this tests：** This tests liberty, paternalism and the harm principle. The interviewer wants you to restate a position accurately before criticising it.

**How to work through it：**
1. Mill’s principle: society may interfere only when conduct harms others; conduct that harms only the agent should be permitted. On that view, a ban lacks justification.
2. The objection: addiction can undermine voluntariness, families and health systems bear external costs, and asymmetric information leads users to underestimate risk. Each may count as harm to others.
3. Give your judgement and name the policy instruments: prohibition, regulation, taxation, education or treatment. They restrict liberty to different degrees.

**The likely follow-up:** Is an addict’s choice voluntary? If not, how does the harm principle change?

### Question 4

**Prompt:** Two countries trade freely. Who gains and who loses? Should the losers be compensated?

**What this tests：** This tests comparative advantage, distribution and political feasibility. The key is to separate aggregate gains from individual losses.

**How to work through it：**
1. Trade lets each country specialise in what it produces at lower relative cost, so total output usually rises and consumers get lower prices and more choice.
2. Workers and capital in import-competing industries may lose jobs or income. The losses are concentrated and visible; the gains are diffuse.
3. The case for compensation: efficiency gains should not leave a specific group bearing all the cost. Retraining, social insurance and regional investment are options, and compensation can make reform politically sustainable.

**The likely follow-up:** Why is trade liberalisation often unpopular politically even when it raises total income?

### Question 5

**Prompt:** A hospital has one ventilator and two patients who will both die without it. What criteria should decide who gets it? Who should decide?

**What this tests：** This tests applied ethics, distributive justice and procedural legitimacy. The interviewer wants you to handle both the principle and the institution.

**How to work through it：**
1. Possible criteria: save the most lives, save the most life-years, first come first served, lottery, or medical urgency. Each has costs.
2. Clinical judgement should rest on prognosis and likelihood of benefit, not social worth, age discrimination or identity. Separate medical criteria from social ones.
3. Procedurally, there should be published guidelines, independent review and a record, to reduce arbitrariness. The decision should sit with a clinical team and ethics committee, not one doctor under pressure.

**The likely follow-up:** Would your answer change if one patient were a doctor treating others?

## Questions
**Do I need to read many original texts in philosophy or economics?**

Some reading helps, but the interview will not test your summary of great books. What matters is using a concept to analyse a concrete question and knowing its limits. Three texts thought through properly are worth more than a list of ten titles.
**What if the interviewer disagrees with my position?**

This is usually a test of your argument, not a judgement of your values. You may hold your position, but you must answer the reasons against it. If the opposing reasons are stronger, revising your position and explaining why is a strength, not a weakness.

## Official sources
- [University of Oxford: a guide to undergraduate interviews](https://www.ox.ac.uk/admissions/undergraduate/applying/guide-for-applicants/interviews)
- [University of Oxford: admissions timeline (decisions on 12 January 2027)](https://www.ox.ac.uk/admissions/undergraduate/applying/admissions-timeline)
- [University of Cambridge: interviews (main period 7 to 18 December 2026)](https://www.undergraduate.study.cam.ac.uk/apply/after/cambridge-interviews)
- [University of Cambridge: how to prepare for your interview](https://www.undergraduate.study.cam.ac.uk/apply/after/interview-preparation)

## Related pages
- [All subject interview questions](https://www.frontiervue.com/interviews/questions)
- [Economics interview questions](https://www.frontiervue.com/interviews/questions/economics)
- [Biology interview questions](https://www.frontiervue.com/interviews/questions/biology)
- [Oxford interviews](https://www.frontiervue.com/interviews/oxford)
- [Cambridge interviews](https://www.frontiervue.com/interviews/cambridge)
- [The TARA exam guide](https://www.frontiervue.com/exams/tara)
