TARA 备考指南
TARA 写作任务范文:三道原创题,三篇完整范文
- 官方范文
- 没有,UAT-UK 从未发布
- 评价依据
- 官方三问结构与 Question Guide 的建议
- 本页内容
- 3 道原创陈述,每道 1 篇完整英文范文
- 篇幅
- 每篇约 380 到 430 词,上限 750 词
- 评分
- UAT-UK 不评分,答卷送到大学
- 官方从未发布范文,网上所谓「标准答案」都没有官方依据。
- 三篇范文用了三种第三问立场:按条件划界、同意但换原因、修正陈述。
- 每篇都在 750 词上限以内,40 分钟里留得出规划时间。
先说清楚:官方没有范文
Explain what you think is meant by the statement
Give a reasoned argument against the statement
To what extent do you agree with the statement?
范文一:考试奖励的是准备还是理解
第一问 · Explain
这句话是什么意思
The statement contrasts two things an exam might reward. "Preparation" can mean learning the material, which no one would object to rewarding, or it can mean learning the exam: its format, its favourite question types and its mark scheme. "Understanding" suggests a grasp that carries over to unfamiliar problems. The statement is only interesting if preparation means the second, narrower thing, so I read it as saying that exams mainly reward familiarity with the exam itself rather than the grasp of a subject they claim to measure. "Reward" matters too: it could mean the marks, or what follows from the marks, such as places and opportunities. Which reading is right matters, because on the broad reading the statement is simply false: rewarding students for learning the material is exactly what exams are for.
先把「准备」拆成两种,再挑出让陈述有争议的那一种。
第二问 · Against
反方论证
First, preparation and understanding are hard to separate. Practising past questions in physics forces a student to apply ideas in many settings, which is how understanding is built, so the student who prepares well usually understands more as a result. The students who have worked through many varied problems are often the same ones who can explain an idea in their own words. Second, well-designed exams are built to defeat narrow preparation. Unseen problems, questions that combine topics and tasks that ask for explanation rather than recall all reward understanding, and a student who has only memorised patterns will struggle with them. Third, the alternatives have the same weakness. Interviews, coursework and portfolios can also be prepared for, often more easily by students with money or advice, so the problem, if it is one, is not special to exams.
三个论点各管一件事:分不开、设计得好的考试防得住、替代方案一样。
第三问 · To what extent
我的立场
I agree with the statement for exams that repeat themselves and disagree for exams that do not. Where an exam asks the same kinds of question year after year, preparation can stand in for understanding, and the statement is largely true. Where an exam deliberately varies its questions, preparation still helps, but only by building the understanding the exam is trying to see. The fair conclusion is that the statement describes a design failure rather than a law about exams: an exam rewards preparation over understanding to the extent that its questions can be predicted. Even then the effect is a matter of degree. A predictable exam does not make understanding worthless; it only lets a well-drilled student without it score nearly as well. That makes the real question less about whether to use exams and more about how to write them, and exams that vary their questions are harder both to write and to revise for, which may be why predictable ones survive.
按「题目能不能被预测」划出同意与不同意的分界。
第一问怎么界定
拆词
preparation 的两种含义
第二问几个论点
三个
分不开 / 好考试防得住 / 替代方案同病
第三问什么立场
按条件划界
取决于题目能否被预测
范文二:省时间的技术为什么很少带来空闲
第一问 · Explain
这句话是什么意思
The statement claims a gap between two outcomes we tend to treat as the same: saving time on a task and having more time for ourselves. It is worth taking seriously, because few people who own a house full of time-saving devices feel they have hours to spare. "Saves time" is clear enough: a washing machine does in an hour what took a morning by hand. "Free time" is harder. It might mean hours with no obligations, or time spent as we choose. "Rarely" also matters, because the statement does not say technology never frees time, only that it seldom does. So the claim is that, in most cases, the time a technology saves is absorbed by something else before it reaches the person as time of their own.
三个词都处理了:省时间、空闲、很少。
第二问 · Against
反方论证
The clearest counter-example is the history of housework. Machines for washing, cleaning and cooking cut the hours needed to run a home, and that change helped make it possible for many more people to take paid work or study. Even if those people did not gain leisure, they gained choice, which is what free time is for. Secondly, some technologies return time directly. A faster commute leaves the evening longer, and a dishwasher run overnight does not create new chores. Online banking and shopping are similar: they remove queues and journeys, and for most people nothing else rushes in to take that time. Finally, the statement may confuse a technology with the expectations around it. If people fill saved time with more work, that is a decision made by them or their employers, not something the technology does.
最后一个反方论点在第三问被接过来,成了立场的理由。
第三问 · To what extent
我的立场
I largely agree with the statement, but for a reason the last argument points to. Saved time is rarely kept because the people who control our time, ourselves included, tend to raise their expectations to match what technology makes possible. Email made messages faster, and the result was more messages, not shorter days. The smartphone made it possible to work from anywhere and so, in many jobs, made it expected to reply from anywhere. Where a technology saves time on a task we had to do anyway, and nobody can easily ask for more of it, the time does tend to come back to us. Where it speeds up work that others can demand more of, the time is usually taken back. So the statement is mostly right, but the cause is social rather than technical, which means it is not inevitable.
大体同意,但把原因从技术改成了社会,结论因此不再是宿命。
第一问怎么界定
逐词界定
saves time、free time、rarely
第二问几个论点
三个
家务史 / 直接还时间 / 技术与期望混为一谈
第三问什么立场
同意但改原因
原因在社会期望,不在技术本身
范文三:该看动机还是看结果
第一问 · Explain
这句话是什么意思
The statement offers a choice between two grounds for judging someone, and it is a choice we make in ordinary life whenever we decide whether to forgive. Intentions are what a person meant to do; results are what actually happened. The two come apart when someone means well and causes harm, or means harm and, by luck, causes none. "Judged" could mean blamed or praised, trusted in future, or punished by law. The statement seems to concern moral judgement of the person, so I read it as claiming that the praise or blame someone deserves depends on what they were trying to do, not on how things turned out.
先说清两者何时分开,再把「评判」限定在道德评价上。
第二问 · Against
反方论证
Firstly, intentions are hidden. We only ever see actions and their results, and anyone can claim afterwards to have meant well. A rule of judging by intentions rewards people who are good at explaining themselves. Secondly, results are what affect other people. A surgeon who means well but is careless still leaves the patient harmed, and it seems wrong to tell the patient that the surgeon should be judged only by good intentions. The law reflects this: dangerous driving that kills is punished far more severely than the same driving that, by chance, harms no one. Thirdly, judging by results gives people a reason to take care. If only intentions counted, there would be little pressure to check one's work, gather information or think about consequences.
每个论点配一个具体人物:会解释的人、外科医生、谨慎的理由。
第三问 · To what extent
我的立场
I agree with the statement up to a point. It seems unfair to blame two equally careless drivers differently just because a child ran out in front of one of them and not the other; the difference is luck, not character. But the surgeon case shows why intentions cannot be the whole story, since taking reasonable care is part of what good intentions should include. My view is that people should be judged by their intentions and the care they took, which are both under their control, rather than by outcomes that depend on luck. Results still matter as evidence about care and as a guide to what must be put right, but they should not settle how good or bad the person is. The law may reasonably work differently, since it has to act on evidence and results are often the best evidence it has.
把陈述修正为「动机加上所尽的注意」,是三篇里最有建设性的立场。
第一问怎么界定
先给分开的情形
好心办坏事、坏心碰巧无害
第二问几个论点
三个
动机看不见 / 结果才伤人 / 看结果才会谨慎
第三问什么立场
修正陈述
看动机与所尽的注意,不看运气
三篇放在一起看
| 范文一 | 范文二 | 范文三 | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 主题 | 教育 | 科技与社会 | 伦理 |
| 第一问的动作 | 拆一个词 | 逐词界定 | 先给分开的情形 |
| 第三问的立场 | 按条件划界 | 同意但换原因 | 修正陈述 |
先自己写
对照三问
常见问题
有没有官方的 TARA 写作范文?
TARA 写作要写多少词?
第三问一定要选边站吗?
可以背范文去考试吗?
更多 TARA 指南
UAT-UK、Pearson、OCR、剑桥大学、帝国理工学院等名称与标识,归各自所有者所有。
把方法用到题上
方添优学上共有 52 套 TARA 卷,其中 18 套是按现行考试格式搭建的 Frontier Original 模考卷,每题配完整解析。2 套 Frontier Original 原创卷与 1 套官方真题回忆版免费试做。